Vow renewals have been steadily gaining popularity in recent years. From intimate ceremonies to elaborate destination events, couples across the world are choosing to reaffirm their commitment in ways that rival, and sometimes surpass, their original weddings. But behind the glittering invitations and Instagram-worthy setups lies a question worth pondering: are vow renewals a genuine celebration of enduring love, or have they become just another cultural trend—a particularly American import designed as a socially acceptable excuse to throw a party?
To answer that, it helps to understand the roots of vow renewals, their evolution, and why they continue to captivate couples, wedding planners, and the media alike.
Table of Contents
The origins of vow renewals: a brief HISTORICAL background
The concept of reaffirming one’s commitment is hardly new. Historically, couples have marked anniversaries and milestones in ways that often resembled modern-day vow renewals. In some cultures, couples would perform rituals to recommit to each other during significant anniversaries, especially when life had presented challenges, such as surviving war, illness, or personal hardships.
In Western contexts, however, the formalisation of vow renewals as an event distinct from a wedding is relatively modern. There is evidence of church ceremonies ‘a thanksgiving for marriage’ for married couples to reaffirm their vows dating back to the 19th century, often tied to milestone anniversaries such as the 25th (silver) or 50th (golden). These events were more solemn than celebratory, focusing on reflection and the acknowledgment of a shared journey rather than spectacle.
The tradition remained niche for decades. Vow renewals were largely reserved for couples who had experienced hardships, or for older generations, where such ceremonies carried moral and spiritual significance rather than social or commercial appeal.
THE RISE OF VOW RENEWALS IN CONTEMPORARY CULTURE
In the late 20th and early 21st centuries, vow renewals began to evolve into a more mainstream cultural phenomenon, particularly in the United States. Several factors contributed to this shift:
- The Wedding Industry Boom: The rise of the multi-billion-dollar wedding industry made celebrations around love and commitment more elaborate than ever. Wedding magazines, reality TV, and social media fuelled a desire not just to marry, but to celebrate that marriage repeatedly, with style.
- Celebrity Influence: High-profile celebrities like Beyonce and Jay Z, David and Victoria Beckham and Sharon and the late Ozzy Osbourne have renewed their vows. Some with elaborate productions and media coverage and others privately. These events helped normalise and glamorise the practice, making it aspirational for the average couple.
- Social Media and Experience Culture: Today, experiences particularly those that can be shared online carry cultural weight. Vow renewals offer the perfect blend of nostalgia, celebration, and photo opportunities. Instagram-ready events and elaborate ceremonies make for content that both celebrates love and signals social status.
- Changing Attitudes Toward Marriage: Modern couples are increasingly interested in personalising their weddings and anniversaries. For many, vow renewals are not about obligation or religion but about reclaiming a commitment in a way that reflects who they are now, rather than who they were on their wedding day.
A CEREMONY WITHOUT LEGAL STRINGS ATTACHED
It’s important to note that vow renewals are purely ceremonial. Unlike a wedding, they carry no legal weight—no new marriage license is required, and the ceremony does not alter a couple’s legal status.
Whether performed in a church, on a beach, or at home, the event is entirely symbolic, serving as a public or private reaffirmation of commitment rather than a legal contract. This ceremonial nature gives couples flexibility to personalise their vows, locations, and format without the constraints of legal requirements, making the renewal an emotional and symbolic milestone rather than a binding legal act.
ARE VOW RENEWALS GIMMICKS? OR MEANINGFUL MILESTONES?
Despite their popularity, vow renewals are often met with scepticism. Critics argue that they can be:
- Commercialised Events: Many vow renewals mirror weddings in expense and extravagance raising the question of whether the ceremony is more about love or social display.
- Socially Prescribed Celebrations: Just as weddings themselves have been critiqued as ritualised social obligations, vow renewals can become a performance, pressured by social norms, friends, and family expectations rather than personal desire.
- American Imports: Some cultural observers point out that while small forms of reaffirmation exist worldwide, the large-scale, party-centric vow renewal is distinctly American in style and substance. Much like Halloween, Black Friday, or Valentine’s Day, the U.S. often repackages traditional ideas into commercially viable, highly publicised experiences.
Yet, dismissing vow renewals as purely gimmicky overlooks their potential depth. For many couples, a vow renewal is profoundly meaningful—a way to mark survival through challenges, celebrate growth, or reaffirm promises in a way that resonates with their current life stage. Unlike a wedding, which can be laden with family politics, planning stress, and expectations, a vow renewal can be entirely self-directed, making it a uniquely personal a
THE PSYCHOLOGY BEHIND VOW RENEWALS
Why do couples feel compelled to renew their vows? Experts suggest several psychological and emotional motivations:
- Acknowledgment of Growth: Marriage is dynamic, and couples evolve together over time. A vow renewal can recognise personal and relational growth, reminding each partner of the journey they’ve taken.
- Ritual and Memory: Humans are ritualistic creatures. Celebrating milestones with ceremonies strengthens emotional bonds and solidifies memories, which can have long-term benefits for relational satisfaction.
- Public Affirmation: For some, reaffirming vows in front of family and friends can reinforce accountability and commitment. It transforms the abstract concept of enduring love into a tangible, social experience.
- Healing and Second Chances: Vow renewals can also serve as a symbolic reset for couples who have weathered rough patches. Recommitting in a ceremonial way provides closure on the past and hope for the future.
TRENDS IN VOW RENEWALS TODAY
Recent trends highlight the diversity of vow renewal experiences:
- Destination Renewals: Couples are embracing travel-oriented vow renewals, sometimes in locations far from their original wedding venue.
- Intimate Gatherings: Not all vow renewals are grandiose. Many couples opt for small, private ceremonies with close family and friends, focusing on connection rather than spectacle.
- Themed Ceremonies: Some couples use vow renewals as an opportunity for creativity—recreating wedding themes, adopting seasonal motifs, or even referencing popular culture.
- Eco-conscious Celebrations: With growing awareness around sustainability, some vow renewals incorporate low-waste practices, blending traditional rituals with modern values.
The variety of approaches demonstrates that while some vow renewals lean into extravagance, others remain intimate, meaningful, and deeply persona
Photo credit: Amy Sampson Photography
CONCLUSION
Vow renewals straddle the line between heartfelt tradition and cultural trend. While critics may dismiss them as gimmicky or overly Americanised, their enduring popularity suggests they fulfill an emotional need that transcends commerce: the desire to pause, reflect, and recommit. Whether lavish or low-key, vow renewals invite couples to honour the journey they’ve shared and to celebrate the promise of the road ahead.
Perhaps, in the end, it doesn’t matter whether vow renewals are a party or a ritual. What matters is that they provide couples with the opportunity to celebrate something precious: the enduring commitment to each other—however they choose to do it.
FINAL THOUGHTS
I’ll admit, I remain in two minds about vow renewals. At times, they can come across as more about the spectacle than the sentiment. But if a couple genuinely wishes to celebrate and reaffirm their continued love and commitment—not simply use a vow renewal as a convenient excuse for another party—then I’m wholeheartedly in favour. I am all about authenticity, and when a renewal is done with intention, honesty, and meaning, it’s worth celebrating. If that’s you, I’d love to hear from you.
